Supreme Court Restricts Geofence Warrants in Chesterfield Case
Google News: Chesterfield CrimePublished
TL;DR
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that police use of geofence warrants to access cellphone location data is a Fourth Amendment search, limiting a powerful law enforcement tool that has grown to tens of thousands of cases annually.
Quick facts
- Who
- U.S. Supreme Court (6-3 decision); Okello Chatrie; Chesterfield County Police; Google
- What
- Supreme Court ruled geofence warrants constitute Fourth Amendment searches and require judicial oversight
- When
- Robbery occurred May 20, 2019; decision issued June 29, 2026
- Where
- Call Federal Credit Union, Midlothian, Virginia (robbery); Supreme Court ruling applies nationwide
The story
On May 20, 2019, an armed robber entered the Call Federal Credit Union in Midlothian, a suburb south of Richmond in Chesterfield County, handed a teller a note demanding cash, and fled with approximately $195,000. Despite witness interviews and surveillance footage, the robber escaped and remained unidentified. Police had little to go on: witnesses saw the suspect approach from an adjacent church while apparently on a cell phone, but that was insufficient to identify him.
On June 14, 2019, Detective Joshua Hylton of the Chesterfield County Police Department applied to a Virginia magistrate for a geofence warrant directed at Google. A geofence warrant draws a virtual perimeter around the crime location and a specific timeframe, then requires the tech company to search its database for all devices that entered that zone. In this case, officers drew a circle with a 150-meter radius around the credit union. Google's Location History service records phone locations approximately every two minutes, and the company produced anonymized data for all users present during the relevant window. Police then narrowed the results and requested that Google unmask certain identities, revealing Okello Chatrie's personal information. His location data showed he entered the geofence roughly ten minutes before the robbery and headed toward a residential area immediately after. He was arrested, prosecuted, and convicted.
Chatrie appealed on Fourth Amendment grounds, arguing that police had conducted a "search" when they accessed his location data without demonstrating particularized suspicion. The case reached the U.S. Supreme Court at a moment when geofence warrants had become ubiquitous: Google received its first such warrant in 2016, 982 by 2018, and over 11,000 by 2020. Tens of thousands of criminal investigations nationwide now rely on the technique, touching hundreds of millions of smartphone users whose location data resides in Google's systems.
On June 29, 2026, in a 6-3 decision led by Justice Elena Kagan and joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Brett Kavanaugh, and Ketanji Brown Jackson, the Supreme Court held that police conducted a Fourth Amendment search when they obtained Chatrie's location information. Justice Kagan wrote that "an individual has a reasonable expectation of privacy in records about his cell phone's location, and police intrude on that constitutionally protected interest when they demand the information." The Court did not strike down geofence warrants entirely, but instead ruled that they trigger full Fourth Amendment scrutiny, meaning officers must now meet stricter standards when seeking them. The justices remanded the case to the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to determine whether the specific geofence warrant in Chatrie's case was "reasonable" under the Fourth Amendment and whether each step of the three-stage search process complied with constitutional requirements.
Key players
- Justice Elena KaganMajority opinion author
- Chief Justice John RobertsMajority vote
- Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Brett Kavanaugh, Ketanji Brown JacksonMajority votes
- Okello ChatrieDefendant in robbery case
- Detective Joshua HyltonChesterfield County Police Department investigator
- U.S. 4th Circuit Court of AppealsCourt reconsidering case on remand
Why it matters
The Supreme Court decision directly affects how police investigate crimes in Chesterfield County and throughout Virginia and the nation. Residents now have explicit constitutional protection against police accessing their location data without meeting heightened Fourth Amendment standards, though the practical impact depends on how lower courts apply the ruling to future cases. The decision also signals the Supreme Court's willingness to extend Fourth Amendment protections to digital information held by tech companies, potentially influencing how police use other forms of data collection in investigations.
Development timeline
Call Federal Credit Union robbed in Midlothian
Armed robber enters bank, hands teller demand note, flees with approximately $195,000. Police have minimal leads from witnesses and surveillance.
Source: Call Federal Credit Union robbed in MidlothianGeofence warrant obtained
Detective Joshua Hylton applies for geofence warrant directed at Google with 150-meter radius around credit union. Google identifies Okello Chatrie as suspect based on location data.
Source: Geofence warrant obtained2019-2020
Chatrie arrested, prosecuted, convicted
Chatrie arrested and prosecuted using geofence warrant evidence. He is convicted and subsequently appeals on Fourth Amendment grounds.
Source: Chatrie arrested, prosecuted, convictedSupreme Court oral arguments
Supreme Court hears oral arguments in Chatrie v. United States on the constitutionality of geofence warrants as Fourth Amendment searches.
Source: Supreme Court oral argumentsSupreme Court decision issued
Supreme Court issues 6-3 decision holding that geofence warrants constitute Fourth Amendment searches. Court remands case to 4th Circuit to determine reasonableness of specific warrant.
Source: Supreme Court decision issued
